easy · Refined Sugar Free

The Creamer of Your Dreams – Sugar-Free Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer

The Creamer of Your Dreams…..

creamer-sweet-cream10We haven’t moved yet, but I still had big plans to roll out a couple of great recipes this week. Then this weekend happened. We went to look at houses about six hours away and out of the blue our SUV decided to break down on us. Let’s just say that it is harder to rent a car on the weekend than you might think! There must have been a massive wedding in town because both the Holiday Inn and Hampton were booked full. Luckily another hotel next door had just opened and they had rooms available. The next day we were finally able to find a car to rent and left town around 3:00 pm, which got us home after 10:00 pm. No worries, there will be a new car parked in my drive way in just a few days. 😉 Needless to say super spectacular recipes just aren’t in the cards this week!

creamer-sweet-cream4creamer-sweet-cream7But I am fulfilling my promise of giving you easy recipes until we move. Today’s recipe was inspired by my favorite coffee creamer of all time. Last year when I gave up drinking store bought coffee creamer I brought you “Sugar-Free Vanilla Creamer”.  This recipe is much simpler, and straight to the point. 😉 For the base I made my own evaporated milk. (You can find my post here for more tips and tricks.) This time I didn’t boil the milk down quite as much. I also used 2% milk, and it is organic so the quality is better, and the color is a bit different.

Right after it begins to boil


Reduced by almost half


I like my coffee pretty sweet, and I know everyone’s preference is different. Even when I would use store bought creamer I would always add extra sweetener. You may find this creamer sweet enough, or you might add extra sweetener to your coffee like I do. When you reduce the milk it begins to sweeten on its own, even without any additional sweetener, but if you want an indulgent coffee….

creamer-sweet-cream5You may find this recipe kind of time consuming, it takes about 45 minutes, but you don’t have to stand with it the entire time. I can get pretty impatient when it comes to bringing ingredients to a boil, so I cranked this one up on high and stirred it every couple of minutes until it started boiling and then turned the heat down to medium. BEWARE! If you use this method, you will have to lift the pan a few times after you reduce the heat so it doesn’t boil over. But once it starts to reduce, after about 10 minutes, you can walk away and stir it about every 10 minutes until the volume of milk decreases by half. You will notice the color will turn a little bit yellow, and it will begin to smell sweet.

This is what you want to toss


If you really don’t want to take the time to make your own evaporated milk you can absolutely buy evaporated milk at the store, but I will warn you that it does have additives in it aside from “just milk”. Carrageenan is the ingredient that I despise the most in so many products, and evaporated milk has it. (A seaweed additive that is used for thickening, and our bodies are unable to digest it.) There are certain brands that don’t have it, but they will cost you a bit more. This creamer literally has two ingredients, milk and Truvia. You can’t go wrong with that! If you are on the fence about sugar alcohols, you can use Stevia instead. 😉 Either way, at the end of the day you will feel really good about what you are putting in your body, and you will be loving your coffee at the same time! Then you can sit back, relax, and enjoy!

creamer-sweet-cream3What kind of coffee creamer do you use?

What is your favorite flavor of coffee creamer?

Sugar-Free Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer

creamer-sweet-creamBy Angie Gouchenour


3 cups 2% milk reduced down to 1 ½ – 1 ¼ (I used Kirkland Organic)

4 teaspoons Truvia zero calorie sweetner


In a large, heavy bottomed pan, bring the milk to a boil, and then reduce to a simmer (See helpful hints here)

Simmer for approximately 30-45 minutes, stirring about every 10 minutes, until the milk is reduced by approximately half

Allow the milk to cool

Using a mesh strainer, strain the milk over a measuring cup to get any “skin” removed from the milk

Add the Truvia and transfer the creamer into a bottle with a lid

Store in the refrigerator for up to 14 days

2 thoughts on “The Creamer of Your Dreams – Sugar-Free Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer

  1. I was thinking about you and wondering how the move was going. 😐 Sorry to hear about the hangup. I was remembering your awesome potato soup recipe. (On my list of things to cook next.) It might be worth a recycle – that is one of your most AWESOME EASY RECIPES – I will never cook potato soup any other way again. Hoping things smooth out with the move. in lak’ech, Debra

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Awe thank you Debra! I have been “recycling” a lot on my Facebook page. Funny my #1 searched post is on how to ripen a banana in the microwave. Wow! 😉 Everything will work out. Hope you enjoy your potato soup! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s